@GMYSTERY In Marcus's own words, it's too good to do a picture show on. It's amazing. Everyone knows it's amazing. There would be nothing to comment on.
I occassionally miss stuff like that happening when my internet was bad and someone would ask a question, cut to the other person thinking, then it starts buffering.
This movie was such a good payoff to the first two films. I love how the tone was entirely different from the others. Even though the previous movies had some serious tones, the darker themes and serious tones are more prevalent all throughout this movie, which I love because of the emotional story beats we get from the film. It’s amazing that the Shrek films grew in tone and seriousness alongside its initial viewers from the first film, (but obviously we don’t talk about The Third).
I was so sad after it didn't come out for Halloween, was an annual thing I looked forward to, so i'm super happy to see that it still happened! It has been a great adventure, thanks so much for all the years!
In their “Shrek the Third” picture show, Marcus and Meg both predicted that “Shrek Forever After” was worse, but I’m happy to see them immediately change their tune 10 minutes in!
its a crime that the transformers 3 video got taken down, that was seriously the funniest video I've watched in so long. I tried showing my friends it and it was gone then I cried
This in my opinion is the best Shrek movie. Better than the first. Of course if you only ever saw Shrek as "lol meme fart joke" then you arent going appreciate it. It isnt the World showing Shrek that he is ungreatful, after his "Happily Ever After" he grew to think his life was pointless, but Rumple Stiltskin showed him a world where he never existed, and it made him realize that he was a hero. Its also an inverted version of the first movie, because there it was a normal Kingdom oppressing Fairy-Tale Creatures, in this Movie, a group of Fairy-Tale creatures are oppressing everyone else. The stakes are also higher, because in the first or even Second movie, Shrek always had the choice to walk away and live his life in his Swamp, he never has this option in Shrek 4 Ever After. Thanks for listening to my Onion-Talk.
I do in fact like 4. I think it does a lot for the characters; what-if story lines can do that. You can explore things they never talk about, that they keep hidden about themselves. I do not like 3 though. Also they got a chance to be creative and the visuals are cool. The reimagining of the world.
1.I honestly never understood the hate for this movie. I mean, yeah, I get that people were pretty sour on the franchise because of how bad Shrek the Third was but this movie gave a pretty decent ending to Shrek's story and its a fun movie on its own merits 2. The opening minutes are a pretty good synopsis about what the franchise became after Shrek the Third. Loud, annoying and obnoxious; with Shrek's desire to go back to before he met Fiona mirroring how the fans felt. 3. I love Marcus's arc through watching the movie. He went from expecting it to be bad, to tolerating it, to thinking its pretty interesting and decent, to actually kinda liking it
I never paid any mind to this movie, but it looks way more nuts, in a fun way, than I ever would've thought. Also Marcus's comparison of Knives Out came so out of left field, but it works so well.
I like the implication in this movie that Shrek's birth somehow caused either the extinction of ogres in his timeline or at least a significantly lower population of them.
Shrek's Cha is probably his third highest stat after Str and Con. He's not super Dex or Int, but he does have moderate Wis because of the onion speech. But he for sure gets by on high charisma, that's his saving trait
“I usually just tune Marcus out when he starts a sentence with ‘The implications…’ “ is pretty much how i think all my friends see me except “the implications” is actually anything I start a sentence with
Had all my friends over one time and my best friend says "Hey so I have the entire fourth movie of shrek downloaded onto my phone" we proceeded to watch the whole thing saying how good it was
Love your content Marcus!!! Been tuned in since your Twilight watch series and been hooked since! You should do a review/watch party on the National Lampoons Christmas Vacation for the holiday season! I would watch the hell out of it!!!!
Next year you should do the weird cassette audio sequel they did. I remember listening to it in the car. Pretty sure shit goes down, they drown the ghost of Farquad if I'm not mistaken?? Anyway, obviously it's a masterpiece.
Okay so like I’m hoping they’re gonna continue Shrektober with puss in boots or something , but just saw the new one so now I’m hoping they’re gonna watch it
Marcus I loved your TF 1 & 2 videos although I think you should do the ending to TF2. Never thought you’d release a third and it was by far the best content from any Clip-Sharer. I was dying the entire video and was so entertained. Hope you can re upload soon and it remains faithful to the original
Entertainment
Can't believe he finally reached the 3rd movie of the Shrek trilogy!
Exactly. Shrek the third is a fever dream
@ Pascal G. Wait, what’s Shrek the third again?
@YourAveragePlayer432 Just non-canon fan fiction, nothing important
@Marcus Holder a fundraiser for shrek forever after
@YourAveragePlayer432 it’s what the fans call Shrek Forever After, since that should’ve been the title for the fourth one instead.
As a shrek 4 defender I’m very happy that I was redeemed
Ι didn't realise people hate it
If you pretend Shrek 3 doesn't exist you've got a pretty much perfect trilogy
Actually, I think that you can pretend it didn’t exist without any continuity problems 🤔
@Pascal G. No one really does, that's 3.
Shrek 4 slaps imo
Loving the redemption arc of “this looks lame as hell” to “oh shit this is actually decent”
This is decent film but not really good.
@Sara Samaletdin nah its downright good and a retrospective for the whole series.
@Sara Samaletdin it has its problems and is not a comedy like the others, but it's really entertaining. It's definitely good enough
@Guilherme Ribeiro I'm glad it went down the dark path tbh
I'm beginning to forget what Marcus sounds like when he's not sick. He can't stop being sick someone help him 🤧
Healthy Marcus is basically 2% less vocal fry
He sounds about the same honestly
Did he take the jab?
Watch the star wars the clone wars video he sounds so young but that was 5-6 years ago
Marcus doubling down on that brief Walmart bit is HYSTERICAL for some reason
was thinking the exact same thing
What part of the video is this 😂
@Fredegunde Stratton 16:50
Is was how deadpan he was that made it so funny
Not a bit that shits true
Don’t think we’re not expecting a shrecktober viewing of Puss in Boots.
Another film I actually think is decent, maybe that's an unpopular opinion
@A Person Nah man, Puss in Boots is awesome! I love that movie.
Don't forget the Sequel
@GMYSTERY In Marcus's own words, it's too good to do a picture show on. It's amazing. Everyone knows it's amazing. There would be nothing to comment on.
Pusscember
I was disappointed by the lack of Shrektober this year, luckily Cosmonaut and his friends came in clutch when I thought all hope was lost
Why do I see you everywhere?
Maybe we’ll have Shrekmas next year
@☠︎ arggg ☠︎ Well then they have to watch Shrek The Halls
@Blue-Apple Where else do you see me?
@Icy Diamond I forgor
"I still don't think it was very good."
"SOMEONE IS GONNA MAIL A BOMB TO YOUR HOUSE!"
I'm already on it
Perfect
Yes mr. homeland security guy, this one right here
Woah look it’s unorthodox individual!
Your FBI agent must be real relaxed for them to let this slide
The silence and horrified look on all of their faces at 15:37 is my new favorite moment on this channel
Dan isn’t horrified, he’s got a huge smile haha
Marcus: 😳
Megan: 😱
Dan: 😃
15:36 the genuine horror in marcus' voice
sounds like it could be used for a tik tok meme
Shrek is so nimble because he’s considered small in his race. He has a ninja build in their world lol
Marcus is so powerful that he can retroactively turn the entirety of November into Shrektobor.
Truly a force to be reckoned with.
The shot of everyones mouth gaping open after the Cookie guy dies sent me to the fucking moon
15:38 😂🤣😂
"The cookie guy"
@Expendable Indigo I was high when I typed it I forgot his name dont @ me
Marcus’ scream 😂
Not everyone, Dan is GRINNING huge haha
We can only hope there will be another Shrektober one day. Let's enjoy this one to the fullest, friends!
Please no, I don't want DreamWorks to ruin Shrek.
@Skyrus456 there’s more Shrek stuff they can watch…
There is still the puss in boots movie. Unless they've already watched it and I just missed it
there's always shreck 2 since the last time they tried it, it got messed up
I'm pretty certain there is a Shrek 5 in development.
I really do love how all 3 of them are just genuinely funny without trying.
i'll never forget "that's a low blow from a tall girl'
@Dankerbell, Ruriko's Chosen “Is this all I am, a tall girl”
“Cause I feel very small now”
@Adloquium Dubious
“This is not good dunkles, I am in witness protection. Help me dunkleman, help me be unpopular.”
“I’m sorry I’m enjoying this movie, I’m missing your bits” is the best compliment this movie could’ve gotten.
That's Marcus' secret, he's always sick
Sick bro
I was chuckling from Marcus’ reaction to Gingy’s death, but I was DYING when the video had cut from that and straight to an ad. Fantastic timing lol
I occassionally miss stuff like that happening when my internet was bad and someone would ask a question, cut to the other person thinking, then it starts buffering.
I loved Megan's "You guys do stuff without me?!" It was such a genuine moment
So cute
Marcus unknowingly repeating everyone’s jokes is so funny
It's still Shrektober in our hearts
Always has been
It can always be Shrektober if you put All Star on loop forever.
Literally watching this on Christmas lmao
15:34 Marcus' "OH MY GOD!" is so hilariously genuine!
Ok
i'd just like to congratulate dan on "shrekhdel test"
15:38 the two are shocked and Dan is just smiling because Gingys dead 😂
I never have laughed out loud harder than I did at “shrektel test”
3:11 Marcus’s coughing syncs up with Rumplestiltskin shaking the paper
I'm in love with Meg and her outfit is on fire in this video.
I just watched the last Shrek video right before and I liked her blond/brunette look better.
Yeah... I hate to be that guy, but she really knows what she's doing with that skirt
@Amf I can say that because I also wear skirts.
@Tribrachidium heraldicum I'm jealous
She's smoking
15:38 I love how both of them are terrified and Dan is just smiling
It’s like that one gif
I would love to see a review of the entire Lord of the Rings/Hobbit series from you. Setting it up the way you reviewed the Harry Potter series.
I agree. Maybe he can throw in rings of power too, I bet he'd have a lot of opinions on that show.
Let’s gooo this man did it!
Sad that we never got a proper Shrek 2 vid, but glad to see the saga come to a seamless close~
Thank you Cosmonaut Crew for giving us one last time old Shrektober vid 🫡
We still have the musical
So many quality jokes in here, and yet I'm still laughing at "he looks like Dream" XD
Shane Dawson got me because I can’t unsee it now
Shrek's power couldn't be contained to a mere d&d stat sheet
I was scared that it wasn’t going to happen this year but now my life is complete again.
These are unironically my favorite Marcus videos he makes.
8:27, man, the fact that he caught that had me dying.
This movie was such a good payoff to the first two films. I love how the tone was entirely different from the others. Even though the previous movies had some serious tones, the darker themes and serious tones are more prevalent all throughout this movie, which I love because of the emotional story beats we get from the film. It’s amazing that the Shrek films grew in tone and seriousness alongside its initial viewers from the first film, (but obviously we don’t talk about The Third).
@text-6429 Tracka
This movie is not a payoff, it's an insult
@Strange Faced How so?
In a couple of years we will all be here for Shrek 5: The Last Shrek To Be Defeated
Shrek 5: It’s All Ogre Now
I've been outside in the cold dark for an hour waiting to be picked up so thank you Marcus for giving me this little bit of entertainment.
Did you make it home ok?
@Lucas Robinapparently not
I was so sad after it didn't come out for Halloween, was an annual thing I looked forward to, so i'm super happy to see that it still happened! It has been a great adventure, thanks so much for all the years!
The sheer disbelief they had when Gingy got eaten is priceless.
God it's so good to see you all together again
Love y'all, thank you for all you do
So glad the three of you still take time to do these
Shrekdel Test was impeccable, amazing, A+ pun and delivery
Can we simply take a moment to congratulate how much time and passion he put into these vids?
In their “Shrek the Third” picture show, Marcus and Meg both predicted that “Shrek Forever After” was worse, but I’m happy to see them immediately change their tune 10 minutes in!
@text-7171 Tracka
I literally got so excited when Meg came back
that take at 15:50 was revelatory. I don't think my life will ever be the same again.
I like how right when the Final Shrektover is posted a month later we get the Last Wish teasing a Shrek 5 seems like we aren't over yet!
Thanks for watching and commenting text me I have something special for you 🎁🎉
🎁
its a crime that the transformers 3 video got taken down, that was seriously the funniest video I've watched in so long. I tried showing my friends it and it was gone then I cried
This in my opinion is the best Shrek movie. Better than the first. Of course if you only ever saw Shrek as "lol meme fart joke" then you arent going appreciate it. It isnt the World showing Shrek that he is ungreatful, after his "Happily Ever After" he grew to think his life was pointless, but Rumple Stiltskin showed him a world where he never existed, and it made him realize that he was a hero.
Its also an inverted version of the first movie, because there it was a normal Kingdom oppressing Fairy-Tale Creatures, in this Movie, a group of Fairy-Tale creatures are oppressing everyone else. The stakes are also higher, because in the first or even Second movie, Shrek always had the choice to walk away and live his life in his Swamp, he never has this option in Shrek 4 Ever After.
Thanks for listening to my Onion-Talk.
Until someone points me to a video where Marcus doesn’t sound sick I’m going to just assume he permanently has an incurable cold
OH HELL YEAH! This has been one heck of a journey. I'm just sad that it's all ogre now 😭
Next year, I hope we get a real Shrek 2 (the best shrek) picture show, I feel like its been long en ough
The only good thing about my year so far was watching this video. Thanks cosmonaut crew
I saw the final scene as a kid and I realized how good this movie was.
Thanks for watching and commenting text me I have something special for you 🎁.
I love how they just geniunely loved the movie
19:29
@Tony that was just dan
“He looks like Dream.” 💀
2:47 is the revelation my subconscious has been searching for.
I can finally sleep for the first time since Dream's face reveal
😂😆🤣 Every time I watch y’all watching something it’s pure COMEDY GOLD! Love you guys!
Let’s hope Shrek 5 does come out just so we can get more of this enthralling series of videos.
I do in fact like 4. I think it does a lot for the characters; what-if story lines can do that. You can explore things they never talk about, that they keep hidden about themselves. I do not like 3 though. Also they got a chance to be creative and the visuals are cool. The reimagining of the world.
1.I honestly never understood the hate for this movie. I mean, yeah, I get that people were pretty sour on the franchise because of how bad Shrek the Third was but this movie gave a pretty decent ending to Shrek's story and its a fun movie on its own merits
2. The opening minutes are a pretty good synopsis about what the franchise became after Shrek the Third. Loud, annoying and obnoxious; with Shrek's desire to go back to before he met Fiona mirroring how the fans felt.
3. I love Marcus's arc through watching the movie.
He went from expecting it to be bad, to tolerating it, to thinking its pretty interesting and decent, to actually kinda liking it
15:38 is the most amazing frame out of any of these videos lmao your guys’ reaction is priceless.
I actually really like this movie. good comedy, great story with stakes and emotional core, and a really good ending to send off the franchise
please continue to watch more Shrek bonus content each year, do not let the tradition die
Dan: Yeah, I still don't think it was very good
Schaffrillas: I can feel a disturbance in the force
The finale we were all waiting for.
So glad they finally watched this one! Funniest Picture Show yet!
Happy late thanks giving Marcus to u and the other cosmonauts,thank uuu for this video guys🖤
I love it when the Golden trio watch movies together, hopefully we'll see more soon
Comparing Rumple to Dream had me rolling! 😂🤣
god damn this video is so fuckin funny. the jokes and the edits are so on point it's ridiculous
I'm excited for this (almost) yearly tradition of Shrek, but I'm sad it's ending 😩
I never paid any mind to this movie, but it looks way more nuts, in a fun way, than I ever would've thought. Also Marcus's comparison of Knives Out came so out of left field, but it works so well.
I like the implication in this movie that Shrek's birth somehow caused either the extinction of ogres in his timeline or at least a significantly lower population of them.
Of all your movie viewings, this is the one that made me laugh the most. That Kingdom Hearts joke at the end was GOLD
Shrektober… I missed this trio so much!
We need an annual Christmas movie viewing. 🙏
I’ve been on this journey with you guys since 2019 too now, let’s just say I’m emotional…….
Shrek's Cha is probably his third highest stat after Str and Con. He's not super Dex or Int, but he does have moderate Wis because of the onion speech. But he for sure gets by on high charisma, that's his saving trait
always good to see the trio on screen!
Shrekdel test line was a banger
I didn't love Shrek 3, but I really enjoyed Shrek 4. It came out when I was 10 and was a perfect end to an era.
“I usually just tune Marcus out when he starts a sentence with ‘The implications…’ “ is pretty much how i think all my friends see me except “the implications” is actually anything I start a sentence with
Had all my friends over one time and my best friend says "Hey so I have the entire fourth movie of shrek downloaded onto my phone" we proceeded to watch the whole thing saying how good it was
Shrek the 4th is definitely a heartwarming movie!! 💚
Love your content Marcus!!! Been tuned in since your Twilight watch series and been hooked since! You should do a review/watch party on the National Lampoons Christmas Vacation for the holiday season! I would watch the hell out of it!!!!
@text-7171 Tracka
deadpan saying ''that's funny'' instead of laughing. love it
“No day drinking doesnt make you a bad father.”
Marcus….everything ok?
Next year you should do the weird cassette audio sequel they did. I remember listening to it in the car. Pretty sure shit goes down, they drown the ghost of Farquad if I'm not mistaken?? Anyway, obviously it's a masterpiece.
That’s Shrek 4D as well
I think Meghan's hair is great and she makes incredible solo and cosmonaut content
I actually LOVE this one. Don't know why a lot of people dissliked this one
Okay so like I’m hoping they’re gonna continue Shrektober with puss in boots or something , but just saw the new one so now I’m hoping they’re gonna watch it
This is genuinely the best movie to ever end an animated franchise!!!
Used to be Toy Story 3, but then 4 came in and fucked that all up. Shrek 4 is pretty great.
How to Train Your Dragon 3 wants to know your location
@J.D. Laney Toy Story 4 was great!
@uknownada disagree. Ruined Woody’s character way worse than people say TLJ ruined Luke.
@J.D. Laney Exaggerating.
Marcus I loved your TF 1 & 2 videos although I think you should do the ending to TF2. Never thought you’d release a third and it was by far the best content from any Clip-Sharer. I was dying the entire video and was so entertained. Hope you can re upload soon and it remains faithful to the original
I do not know any adult that loves Shrek as much as this man.
I am a 22 year old boyman, and I love Shrek 1, 2, and Forever After
Schafrillas Production: Am I a joke to you?
Marcus's comments during this were really wholesome lol
I was wondering when we would get this. Let’s goooooo!
This movie is actually good, and the only reason people think its bad is because the previous movie was so terrible.
YOOOOOOOO I didn't know Megan moved with you guys. Good to see you all together again!