Tap to unmute

How did the Phoenicians Colonize the Mediterranean Sea?

Share
Embed
  • Published on May 30, 2023 veröffentlicht
  • Happy Birthday, Nord! Get exclusive NordVPN deal here: nordvpn.com/knowledgianord
    It's risk-free with Nord's 30-day money-back guarantee!
    How did the Phoenicians Colonize the Mediterranean Sea?
    Phoenicia was a thalassocracy that existed as early as 2500 BC and held territory throughout the Levant. The Phoenicians were not necessarily members of one united nation, but instead, made up a series of independent city-states such as Tyre and Byblos; though they nonetheless served as some type of unified front when it came to the colonization of the Mediterranean.
    ♦Consider supporting the Channel of Patreon and gain cool stuff:
    www.patreon.com/Knowledgia
    ♦Please consider to SUBSCRIBE : goo.gl/YJNqek
    ♦Music by Epidemic Sound
    ♦Sources :
    Phoenician Secrets: Exploring the Ancient Mediterranean Paperback - Sanford Holst
    Phoenicians: Lebanon's Epic Heritage - Sanford Holst and Antoine Khoury Harb Ph.D.
    Odyssey - Homer, translated by Stanley Lombardo
    The Phoenicians and the West: Politics, Colonies and Trade - Maria Eugenia Aubet
    The encyclopedia of ancient history -Roger S Bagnall - Malden, MA : Wiley-Blackwell, 2012.
    Phoenicia - John Kenrick
    The world of the Phoenicians; (History of civilization) - Sabatino Moscat
    History of Phoenicia Paperback - George Rawlinson
    ♦Script & Research :
    Skylar Gordon
    #History #Documentary #Phoenicia

Comments • 595

  • Knowledgia
    Knowledgia  Year ago +47

    Happy Birthday, Nord! Get exclusive NordVPN deal here: nordvpn.com/knowledgianord
    It's risk-free with Nord's 30-day money-back guarantee!

    • SCINTILLAM DEI
      SCINTILLAM DEI Year ago

      YugoslavianMapping1291 [IMA] [YUC] [GBS] NEVER GONNA LET YOU DOWN

    • Dayang Marikit
      Dayang Marikit Year ago +1

      The way that the Phoenicians expanded their influence, reminds me of Manila in the Philippines… by the way, I apologize in advance because this would be a lengthy comment.
      By the time of Spanish contact, Manila had monopolized the archipelago’s trade, that they managed nearly all inter-island and inter-ethnic exchanges, therefore all of the other polities became reliant on Manila. In fact the Spaniards mentioned that the Manila Moros brokered deals with the rules of Cebu to allow them to settle on the island. The Spaniards also mentioned that Manila Moros who were settled in Butuan in the Southern island of Mindanao, ordered the locals to not deal with the Spaniards if it wasn’t silver that was being traded, and the locals obeyed. The Spaniards mentioned a Manila Moro paramount ruler who was well known throughout the islands that he was respected and treated almost like a king.
      At first, the Spaniards incorporated themselves into the trading network/colony that Manila had created. The Spaniards were importing silver that they mined in the Americas, which the Manila merchants wanted, because the Chinese mainly accepted silver in exchange for their products. Eventually the Spaniards grew to become more and more influential due to silver and they gained a lot of local allies. Among these was the Manila Moro merchant whose name is ‘Mahomar’. He had been dealing with the Spaniards in Cebu for years and he had become well acquainted with them, so he decided to bring the Spaniards back with him to Manila, to make deals with the ruling family to allow them to settle near the city. This would make things more convenient, because silver would flow directly to Manila, which they could easily trade with Chinese and Japanese merchants who were settled near Manila. Unfortunately Rajah Sulayman refused the offer and ordered them to head back to their settlement in Cebu. Somewhere in their conversation, fighting broke out. Some sources claim that it was Rajah Sulayman who first fired a (lantaka)/locally made pre-colonial cannon, while other sources claim that it was the Spaniards who fired a cannons first. Manila would fall to the Spaniards and their allies. This is how the Spaniards took over what is now the Philippine archipelago. When Manila fell, the Spaniards basically took control of the trading network/colony that Manila had already woven prior to their arrival. They simply gave it a name, and that’s how the Philippines was born.
      There were several attempts by the local elites to get rid of the Spaniard. First was the Battle of Bangkusay Channel, where relatives and allies of the ruling family came to Manila from the regions of Navotas, Bulacan and Pampanga to aid them against the Spaniards, but this unfortunately failed and some nobles were executed. The next attempt is known as the “Tondo Conspiracy”… this was when the ruling family and nobles attempted to contact their relatives in the Bruneian royal court. Unfortunately this failed again because a man named ‘Surabao’ revealed their plans. It is uncertain why Surabao snitched on them, but it is speculated that the reason might also have something to do with silver as well, because if they successfully get rid of the Spaniards, the steady flow of silver into the archipelago would stop. After this revelation, many of Manila’s royals and nobles were harshly punished, some were executed, while others were exiled to Latin America or heavily taxed. Those who allied with the Spaniards, we’re able to keep their wealth, properties and social status. The Spaniards gave these people or their descendants the “Principalia status” which was basically the “colonial noble class”.
      I highly recommend the article (Transforming Manila: China, Islam and Spain in a Global Port City) by Ethan Hawkley.

  • Expanded History
    Expanded History Year ago +251

    The rich and in depth history of the Phoenician empire (if you would call it that) is that of underrated value and little to no knowledge to majority of people unfortunately. Thank you for making this video and brining more light to it!

    • Seth Koch
      Seth Koch Year ago +10

      What are you doing here ExpandedHistory!? I love ur military history channel!

    • Nperez1986
      Nperez1986 Year ago +4

      Thanks Age Of Empires Demo on Windows 98 back in the day I learned about them :). We can thank our alphabet to them as well :)

    • BabyJake 777
      BabyJake 777 Year ago

      The e Phoenicians we're Canaanites. The Canaanites are Hamites. Hamites are black people!

    • Canadian MMA Guy
      Canadian MMA Guy Year ago +4

      @BabyJake 777 we wuz kangz n shit! The blacks of iraq bruddah

    • BabyJake 777
      BabyJake 777 Year ago

      @Canadian MMA Guy Yes Nimrod was the son of Kush(Ethiopia). The Kushites built the Babylonian cities(Modern Iraq) and his title was King. So you're correct!

  • Eric
    Eric Year ago +107

    As an archaeology master's student working on the Phoenicians and, their successor, Carthaginians, the principal motivation for both Phoenician and Greek trade networks and trading posts which eventually became colonies was getting mineral resources, notably metals like iron, gold and bronze. The reason the Phoenicians and Carthaginians are less known is due to the fact they lost against Europe's “ancestors“ Greece and Rome. I'd argue they all played a huge role in forming the modern Mediterranean world.
    Fun fact: the Greeks, who isolated themselves after the Bronze Age collapse, worked closely with the Phoenicians when reopening there trade ties. The Greeks adopted and readapted the Phoenician alphabet, and the Romans adopted and readapted the Greek alphabet, turning it into the Latin alphabet, which continues today.

    • bohemianwriter1
      bohemianwriter1 Year ago +1

      The 'Bronze Age collapse.
      I'm still pondering what caused it.
      Natural disasters, or raids from the sea peoples?
      Or both?
      'I know that Santorini's volcano have had its share of outbreaks-
      I've been there.

    • Eric
      Eric Year ago

      @bohemianwriter1 There's still a lot of debate around this subject. From what I know, there's an economic reasoning. If I remember it's either Egypt or Crete's cities that collapsed and due to the economic interdependence, every interconnected regional power was affected. The cause, no one knows yet

    • Mr.
      Mr. Year ago

      @Eric From what I've heard from most of my collegues (I myself am mostly interested in ancient coins and alike artifacts) it's most probably to be a combination of many of the factors people point to as the "definitive" reason. All combining and kind of snowballing. Though you are very right about no one really knowing anything for sure though.
      But I think it'd make sense for several environmental, cultural and intersocietal factors to have a (kinda lost for the word, English isn't my primary language) but strenghtening effect on eachother that made each worse. After all, seemingly quite stable civilisations were left in disarray one after another in a relatively small amount of time or as a friend of mine likes to say 'an archeological blink of an eye' though I kinda messed up the translation.

    • Nicolas
      Nicolas Year ago

      I have a question off topic. Would you know why did Carthage decide not to help Old Tyre when Alexander the Great was invading it? Wasn't Carthage a colony of theirs? What was the feeling of the other Phoenician cities (Byblos..) when they helped Alexander the Great attack Tyre (also Phoenician but independent city)? Did the people of Tyre hate them after?

    • Jandroid
      Jandroid Year ago

      Imagine if the knew that just close by in the Senegal River sources some of the biggest Gold reserves in the world

  • Mike Hart
    Mike Hart Year ago +277

    Perhaps the most important innovation of the Phoenicians was their alphabet which the Greeks and later the Romans modified and adopted. Way easier than cuneiform or hieroglyphs.

  • kristiawan indriyanto
    kristiawan indriyanto Year ago +329

    The Phoenicians were really underrated compared to Greco-Roman cultures

    • Ben
      Ben Year ago +39

      History is written by the victor

    • Mostafa Slaibeh
      Mostafa Slaibeh Year ago +17

      Because they came from Lebanon since I was a little kid they told us you Lebanese people are Phoenicians what's in it for us nowadays living without electricity civilizations should develop into good for the future some day we'll return the Phoenicians days living instead of moving forward

    • Lambert
      Lambert Year ago +12

      Because Phoenicians were not nearly as interesting as them. Seriously, the two are not even comparable.

    • degamegang
      degamegang Year ago +17

      @Lambert highly doubt that since there religion is quite intresting and same goes for there alphabet and lets not forget there military history

    • the_ corvid
      the_ corvid Year ago +30

      @Lambert Phoenicians aren't interesting? May I present to you... Hannibal Barca!

  • daydreaming
    daydreaming Year ago +61

    This is why i study history and ancient history at the same time I love Phoenicians and their deeds! It takes a lot for some city states to work their way up the ladder and they did it none the less.

    • LIONBOY ☀️Король Кошек☀️
      LIONBOY ☀️Король Кошек☀️ 8 months ago

      🤺☦️🇷🇺Point is that it shows just how accurate the description of them and their trade route in the Bible, and what the curse upon the Canaanites meant in being "slave of slaves to his brothers"

  • ThaMuffinMan
    ThaMuffinMan Year ago +112

    People, look up Hanno the Explorer. The Carthaginian sailor who dared to sail around Africa to Sierra Leona in 600 BC. He didn’t make it all the way, but still a great accomplishment that wasn’t re completed til the Portuguese.

    • ThaMuffinMan
      ThaMuffinMan Year ago +11

      @Canadian MMA Guy He found a tribe of “hairy people” and he called them “gorillai”. He couldn’t capture the men so he captured the women. Gorilla comes from this early term

    • Canadian MMA Guy
      Canadian MMA Guy Year ago +3

      @ThaMuffinMan thank you.
      I was just jesting about how we used to think gorillas, squid, and pandas were myths.. and how told the majority of people still think sasquatch are myth.
      Something else of interest, most canadians don't even know we had penguins 150 years ago. (Great auk).
      It's amazing how information changes in less than two human lives.

    • ThaMuffinMan
      ThaMuffinMan Year ago

      @Canadian MMA Guy wow I didn’t know that either. Couldn’t agree more. Love learning about stuff like this

  • Ray Gagnon
    Ray Gagnon Year ago +33

    “One place had a colony so big it was making smaller colonies.”-The history of the world I guess.

    • Jeffrey V
      Jeffrey V Year ago

      "Now the Phoenicians can get down to business"

  • Raven Gaming
    Raven Gaming Year ago +15

    You left out Malta which was a key trade spot for the famous and noble purple dye at the time. Several remains were found throughout Malta, including the famous cippus, Cippi of Melqart dating back to the 2nd century. This provided the key to the modern understanding of the Phoenician language.

    • M B
      M B Year ago +1

      Didn't even bother to colour us purple :(

    • TuniStick
      TuniStick 11 months ago +1

      sad how didn't he mention yuchedes (the kindom that had the actual penorep (semetic) population in northern spain) :(

    • powerofthought
      powerofthought 10 months ago

      The purple dye that apparently had it's emergence in QPTR, now called Minoans.

  • S T
    S T Year ago +14

    I would like to add some details about their colonization: it wasn't the same in all their conquered territories. Even if the punics conquered the westernmost part of Sicily, they never really subjugate the native elymians (the elymians had many important cities, like Eryx and Segesta), since the latter were pretty much developed. So the punics preferred to create commercial outposts alongside the coast of Western Sicily, with few exceptions

    • S T
      S T Year ago +3

      علي ياسر colonization was not always the same. Most of the times the punics were respectful of the indigenous groups, not like the greeks, for example

  • Big Bootros
    Big Bootros Year ago +58

    The modern European colonies also started like that. As trade posts and layovers for their ships. Then gradually taking over the inland.

    • Miguel Padeiro
      Miguel Padeiro Year ago +21

      The Portuguese empire basically followed the Phonecian method to every word. Small trade outposts trade with the locals, and then we have Brasil...which kind of can be compared to carthage (both became way larger empires than their predecessors)

    • Canadian MMA Guy
      Canadian MMA Guy Year ago +5

      @Miguel Padeiro the carthaginians fled to portugal with allied tribes.
      Lisbon was a carthaginian trading post, the basque region was heavily settled in and in my opinion the uk after that.

    • Saguntum-Iberian-Greek Konstantinopoli
      Saguntum-Iberian-Greek Konstantinopoli Year ago +5

      True, the Spanish started by making a trading post in the americas, the Portuguese, in the Cabo de Boa Esperança (Cape of good hope)

    • ዘየደ ሣህለሥላሴ
      ዘየደ ሣህለሥላሴ Year ago

      @Saguntum-Iberian-Greek Konstantinopoli and Kongo kingdom

    • Weasel
      Weasel Year ago +1

      Except for Spain.
      Spain's original intentions may be different but they wanted gold and destroyed the civilizations and cultures in a truly barbarian way.
      Same with Portuguese.
      British were kinda like that.
      Dutch were different from them during most of their colonial history.

  • Cedar Animation
    Cedar Animation Year ago +14

    Thank you for this history. I try to learn about my country in the ancient world and this is helping me a lot.

    • Wisam Elchayati
      Wisam Elchayati Year ago +2

      It’s amazing how ignorant one can be about her/his own history. There was never a people called the Phoenicians. They were Canaanite city states. “Phoenicians” is what Greeks called purple dye traders from the eastern Mediterranean

    • Cedar Animation
      Cedar Animation Year ago +3

      @Wisam Elchayati If the Greeks called it Phoenicians they are Phoenicians. I know the Canaanites had seperate state like Byblos and Tyre are not the same type of Canaanites. But Tyre made the purple and Byblos aswell. They both traded the purple dye and that's the Greeks called them Phoenicians. And also our generation use a lot of Greek term. Even in Mathematics. So they are using the name Phoenician to specify the empire that sells purple dye. There is other Canaanites that didn't use the purple dye. They didn't even indetefy there self as Canaanites nor Phoenicians. But the Greeks called them Phoenicians

    • Wisam Elchayati
      Wisam Elchayati Year ago +1

      @Cedar Animation they did identify as Canaanite city states. There are records of that, even in Greece. They also taught together when outside empires invaded. If you choose to be ignorant of history than that is one problem, but if you choose to disgrace your ancestors by accepting the name their invaders gave them, then that’s another problem

    • Cedar Animation
      Cedar Animation Year ago +3

      Also, the Greeks didn't really invade us, the only empire that invaded us in Persia. Big defference. The Carthage city turned into in empire. As well why are you fighting if I'm here to learn my history. If you want to change the history, than do a Clip-Share video about your opinion. Since you really need to show your ignorant skills. Go. I won't bother you.

  • Alexandre M
    Alexandre M 11 months ago +8

    I was born in Lebanon, and to see how my country was a beacon of light in the past, and now it is a cradle of filth saddens me... I will keep that beacon shining in my heart.

    • Ankit Gadpayle
      Ankit Gadpayle 2 months ago

      Hi bro, Yes it really sad to see how our countries are now vs how was they. Well I am from India. But good times will come for us.

    • Wayne Winters
      Wayne Winters 24 days ago

      It's just an idea, you had nothing to do with it so having pride in that is cringey, and why limit yourself to a "country", if you wanna have pride in something you had nothing to do with why not just have pride in humanity instead of "my tribe"
      Humans are weird

  • Nenenin Donu
    Nenenin Donu Year ago +52

    They established one of the greatest empires by Mediterranean coastal length, following the likes of Romans and Ottomans

    • thearab59
      thearab59 Year ago +15

      You meaning "preceding the likes of...", but you are right.

    • Nenenin Donu
      Nenenin Donu Year ago +3

      @thearab59 That wouldve been a chronological use I preferred to rank it based on the amount of med. coastal lands ruled which is less than that of the Romans and Ottomans

    • Wanka Wanka
      Wanka Wanka Year ago +4

      @Nenenin Donu the romans had the greatest Mediterranean empire ever they literally owned all of it at some point

  • The Quiet Observer
    The Quiet Observer Year ago +21

    Truly an underrated topic in colonization! Keep up the good work!

  • Avery the Cuban-American

    *"Now the Phoenicians can get down to business!"*

    • PakBall & Sam
      PakBall & Sam Year ago +1

      nice

    • Ajmi Yessine
      Ajmi Yessine Year ago +1

      You are a man of culture I see

    • David Reyes
      David Reyes 11 months ago

      Also, can we switch to a new metal thats a little easier to find?

    • Squidjit
      Squidjit 8 months ago

      I used to see you at the top of every comment section. What happened man?

  • random observer
    random observer Year ago +3

    Sometimes I think of the Greeks and Phoenicians as the bronze/early iron age equivalent of a future Earth sending out generation ships or early FTL ships. Some great ceremony binds the people of the colony to the mother world, then off they go to set up a new world and hopefully keep alive whatever sacred plant or fire from the homeland they took with them to maintain symbolic connection.

  • Westsider Metalhead
    Westsider Metalhead Year ago +15

    In Bulgaria we have a saying that goes something like this "Where are you in such a hurry for like a phoenician?". The original businessmen of the Mediterranean and Europe.

    • Cedars
      Cedars Year ago

      For real? That’s so interesting? Do you have the exact Bulgarian saying? I’d love to learn more about it!

    • TuniStick
      TuniStick 11 months ago +1

      I'm a penorep from spain (descendents of iberio-punic population) and we have an idiom that says "This work wouldn't make you a phoenician" which means don't be so hastly to do this plan that you think will make you wealthy/rich think a lot before deciding, it's used to advise someone who thinks of starting a commercial project or getting an important job :P
      in my language:
      "Đo faggo nȷhe ťaķălŏť úno phınıqus"
      IPA pronounciation:
      [ðɔ faŋo ɲe tæχaloˀt uno ɸiniqœs]

  • Dayang Marikit
    Dayang Marikit Year ago +9

    The way that the Phoenicians expanded their influence, reminds me of Manila in the Philippines… by the way, I apologize in advance because this would be a lengthy comment.
    By the time of Spanish contact, Manila had monopolized the archipelago’s trade, that they managed nearly all inter-island and inter-ethnic exchanges, therefore all of the other polities became reliant on Manila. In fact the Spaniards mentioned that the Manila Moros brokered deals with the rules of Cebu to allow them to settle on the island. The Spaniards also mentioned that Manila Moros who were settled in Butuan in the Southern island of Mindanao, ordered the locals to not deal with the Spaniards if it wasn’t silver that was being traded, and the locals obeyed. The Spaniards mentioned a Manila Moro paramount ruler who was well known throughout the islands that he was respected and treated almost like a king.
    At first, the Spaniards incorporated themselves into the trading network/colony that Manila had created. The Spaniards were importing silver that they mined in the Americas, which the Manila merchants wanted, because the Chinese mainly accepted silver in exchange for their products. Eventually the Spaniards grew to become more and more influential due to silver and they gained a lot of local allies. Among these was the Manila Moro merchant whose name is ‘Mahomar’. He had been dealing with the Spaniards in Cebu for years and he had become well acquainted with them, so he decided to bring the Spaniards back with him to Manila, to make deals with the ruling family to allow them to settle near the city. This would make things more convenient, because silver would flow directly to Manila, which they could easily trade with Chinese and Japanese merchants who were settled near Manila. Unfortunately Rajah Sulayman refused the offer and ordered them to head back to their settlement in Cebu. Somewhere in their conversation, fighting broke out. Some sources claim that it was Rajah Sulayman who first fired a (lantaka)/locally made pre-colonial cannon, while other sources claim that it was the Spaniards who fired a cannons first. Manila would fall to the Spaniards and their allies. This is how the Spaniards took over what is now the Philippine archipelago. When Manila fell, the Spaniards basically took control of the trading network/colony that Manila had already woven prior to their arrival. They simply gave it a name, and that’s how the Philippines was born.
    There were several attempts by the local elites to get rid of the Spaniard. First was the Battle of Bangkusay Channel, where relatives and allies of the ruling family came to Manila from the regions of Navotas, Bulacan and Pampanga to aid them against the Spaniards, but this unfortunately failed and some nobles were executed. The next attempt is known as the “Tondo Conspiracy”… this was when the ruling family and nobles attempted to contact their relatives in the Bruneian royal court. Unfortunately this failed again because a man named ‘Surabao’ revealed their plans. It is uncertain why Surabao snitched on them, but it is speculated that the reason might also have something to do with silver as well, because if they successfully get rid of the Spaniards, the steady flow of silver into the archipelago would stop. After this revelation, many of Manila’s royals and nobles were harshly punished, some were executed, while others were exiled to Latin America or heavily taxed. Those who allied with the Spaniards, we’re able to keep their wealth, properties and social status. The Spaniards gave these people or their descendants the “Principalia status” which was basically the “colonial noble class”.
    I highly recommend the article (Transforming Manila: China, Islam and Spain in a Global Port City) by Ethan Hawkley.

  • EpicnessYeet
    EpicnessYeet Year ago +23

    The phoenicians were really advanced for their time and were really ambitious, while nations like Rome and Sumer surely influence us today with the laws of Rome and the wheel of Sumer, the phoenicians gave us something more important than both, the alphabet.
    We often ignore them for their many feats, the only time the phoenicians are ever mentioned as pretty big are the times of Carthage, but never more, which is so unfair.

    • Thegunslinger Gilead
      Thegunslinger Gilead Year ago +2

      They gave us the alphabet but not vowels.

    • S T
      S T Year ago +2

      There is no point in valuing a civilization more than another: the romams gave us roads, the base for statal administration, laws, and so on. The sumerians gave us the first efficient irrigue system, and the first epic poem. So what's the point?

    • S T
      S T Year ago +2

      Spolierman it seems that your point of you is influenced by nationalism, which is always bad. I will not even try to explain why you're wrong... greetings

    • S T
      S T Year ago +1

      Spolierman yes, we all know how much important was the middle east in ancient times. But denying the importance of other civilizations seems a little nationalistic to me. Good day

    • Weasel
      Weasel Year ago +1

      They didn't gave us alphabet.
      Greeks gave us Alphabets.
      Phonecians had a Abjad.
      It would look like this -
      Phwncyns ddnt wrt wth vwwls, thy wrwt wth nly cwnsnwnts.
      Greeks modified the Phonecian abjad and created seperate letters for vowels.
      Phonecian abjad was itself developed from Egyptian hieroglyphics.

  • Tyler Gray
    Tyler Gray Year ago +5

    I loved the video! But one quick comment I think you may have mixed up the city of Ibiza with the city of Palma, Ibiza is on the left island where as Palma is on the center Island. Keep up the great work!

    • Kristian Törnkvist
      Kristian Törnkvist 4 months ago

      Prob same with Carthage cause it was more where he placed utica. Happens all the time here. They once placed a norweigan city in northern Finland.

  • E L I A S
    E L I A S Year ago +5

    In Morocco there is an Archeological Site Called Lexus with Many Ruins From the Mauritanian and Roman Era of the City of Lexus that was built by the Phoenicians but a few of this Ruins date back also to the Phoenician/Carthaginian period.

    • SunsetNova
      SunsetNova Year ago

      Yes Lixus which is very close to the town Larache

  • Timmy Neutron
    Timmy Neutron Year ago +2

    In my social studies class we do a unit about the Phoenicians, it is very interesting

  • PakBall & Sam
    PakBall & Sam Year ago +51

    imo Phoenicians is one of the most over looked ancient civilizations even tho it is the most interesting and really fun to learn about how it made it's empire with will led to the carthage one of the most interesting things to learn about and a good thing to think and learn about

  • Andrew Fullerton
    Andrew Fullerton Year ago +2

    I'm always curious about how the locals reacted to these colonies. Was an agreement reached with a local ruler? Was territory conquered my force? Was it a mutually beneficial integration?

    • Cedars
      Cedars Year ago

      Mutually beneficial.

    • TuniStick
      TuniStick 11 months ago

      it's an agreement of mutual interest between the two sides ... who the heck will refuse money?

  • Vasile Rogojan
    Vasile Rogojan Year ago +3

    Another reason why the Ancient history should deserves more attention.

  • Harambe
    Harambe Year ago +7

    2:13 this is what I like! I never understood expanding your own territory, just cooperate instead. But I guess reality is that everyone else is armed so you got to be armed yourself, otherwise risk shitty consequences.

  • Liam O'Connell
    Liam O'Connell Year ago +2

    In close to modern times, or middle age times was the Hanseatic league, Genoa, Venice and the trade powers of Spain and Portugal at some points. In the east, there was Malacca and the Chinese Dynasties who established tributaries

  • Space Khan
    Space Khan Year ago +2

    There was actually an interesting fable about the circunavigation of Africa by the Phoinikai on behalf of the Pharaoh , recorded by Herodotus

  • Grasslander
    Grasslander Year ago +12

    Interestingly, this is also how the British empire spread. They first set up trading stations, which then had to be defended, so they grew and armed allied lords or tribes. (Typical pattern in Africa: Set up trade by the coast. Then missionaries come and walk into the interior to preach. Then get eat... killed by the locals, who then also attack the traders. The trade outpost asks for redcoasts to fortify and defend the outpost. They arm coastal tribes, who use the guns to subdue their enemies in the interior. That's also why the coasts turned Christian while the interior turned Muslim, from Muslim missionaries coming across the continent.)

  • Hamze Hachem
    Hamze Hachem Year ago +6

    Lebanon houses a lot of phoenician remnants. It is worth a visit

  • re_tt_es
    re_tt_es Year ago +5

    what tool or software do you use to animate the maps?

  • Mateo Ramirez
    Mateo Ramirez Year ago +2

    Interesting how ancient historians have the phoenicians colonizing in the 12th century bc. That's a lot further back than modern historians

  • Malek Ellouz
    Malek Ellouz Year ago +2

    I loved all the hammers making their own little noises while you talked 😂

  • Abdelhak Smara
    Abdelhak Smara Year ago +1

    Thank you for covering this part of the World.

  • Julien L
    Julien L Year ago +1

    Thanks for your videos. I live and work in Cambodia. I study history and I am in direct contact with a linguist and historian who study Khmer culture et myths as well as several minorities who live in Cambodia - We would love to help you to make a video about Cambodia history and myths.
    Is it possible to send you an email?

  • Vasile Rogojan
    Vasile Rogojan Year ago +5

    One interesting thing is that the Greeks once controlled southern part of the Italian peninsula that makes the Italian population in that area to have Greek heritage.

    • Weasel
      Weasel Year ago +1

      Another interesting fact is that Arabs controlled almost all of Iberia and Sicily and the modern population there still hav some Arab Berber ancestry.

    • TuniStick
      TuniStick 11 months ago

      Also an interesting thing is that an iberio-punic civilization developped in central northern spain, so a punic population is still living there ... at least some of them got civilized and developpement ...

  • Pablo M.
    Pablo M. Year ago +1

    Very interesting video. Just one tiny thing, you set Ibiza in the wrong island of the Balearic (thats Mallorca)

  • Emmanuel Fredenrich - E-Commerce Growth Expert

    Amazing content, thanks!

  • Depek The Great
    Depek The Great Year ago +1

    Well made documentary indeed daily and ever,good friend!!!👍

  • Billy Kotsos
    Billy Kotsos Year ago

    Great Honours belong to the Phoenicians !

  • Snoflakes
    Snoflakes 11 months ago +1

    So how did they do it? The entire video explains what made the Phoenicians so great, their accomplishments and their legacy. But nothing really dives deeper into the 'how' of it. In my mind, they were just another trading people in the levant, only more successful. Idk why though

  • Broken Bridge
    Broken Bridge Year ago +3

    Nice video. The Phoenicians are underrated by many. Shame.

  • Uzair Ahmed
    Uzair Ahmed Year ago +1

    Fantastic video today keep it up your doing amazing job

  • 38th Panzer Division

    You forgot Malta as well most of our architectures and genes come from there!!

  • bohemianwriter1
    bohemianwriter1 Year ago +4

    What I love about these history channels, is that they are content free of a religious bias.

  • Vasile Rogojan
    Vasile Rogojan Year ago +4

    One important thing about the Phoenicians is that theirs alphabet which was adopted and modified by the Greeks and later the Romans which way later remained the latin alphabet used by the majority of the world countries.

    • Weasel
      Weasel Year ago

      Phonecians had an Abjad not an Alphabet.
      An Abjad is a type of writing system which only writes consonants and no vowels while an alphabet is a type of writing system which writes both consonants and vowels with seperate letters.
      All writing systems are not an alphabet but all Alphabets are a writing system.

    • TuniStick
      TuniStick 11 months ago

      yes we use both: the penorep script which is an alphabet and peno-arabic script which is an abjad also, also we write in social media (i mean if we're using a computer or a phone) we write in latin but ... a bit different. For example the sentence: "it's Winter, how cold it is!" would be in the latin script "Jǐť'ĩ l'esťré, Ke ĩ frwadus! "

    • TuniStick
      TuniStick 11 months ago +1

      and in the peno-arabic equivalent script:
      " جٍت'ئن ل'يسترِ. كِ ئن فروَٕدٌس! "

  • Omar Kaj
    Omar Kaj Year ago +8

    I always thought the Phoenicians only settled in Tunisia. Wasn't aware of their settlements in Algeria, Morocco, and Europe.

    • DanRyzESPUK
      DanRyzESPUK Year ago +4

      A quarter of Spanish cities in the mediterranean were founded by phoenicians. Malaga and Cadiz (called Gades) were founded by them. Sagunto was too.

    • Slimane Ismailli
      Slimane Ismailli Year ago

      @DanRyzESPUK Cartagena in Spain exist

    • Nisar BO
      Nisar BO Year ago +1

      They settled from modern day Libya to Morocco, Sicily, Sardinia, Corsica, Spain & Portugal. The capital of Portugal Lisbon was founded by them too as a trading outpost called "Alis Ubbo"

  • Joseph Phoenix
    Joseph Phoenix Year ago

    Great Episode!

  • RotStern25
    RotStern25 Year ago

    Hello, great video, I have a suggestion.
    Why did the inca empire collapse?

  • Unique Glow
    Unique Glow Year ago +1

    There were several important cultural and political centers all over the Mediterranean region in Antiquity, and there were various sorts of changing interactions and exchanges between Phoenicians, Carthaginians, Greeks and others. The influence of Phoenician culture did not end quickly or suddenly.
    The father of Pythagoras, Mnesarchus, was a merchant from the city of Tyre. Thales was of Phoenician descent and a descendant of Cadmos. The founder of Stoicism, Zeno of Kitium, was of Phoenician origin. The geographer and astronomer Marinus of Tyre influenced the geographer and astronomer Claudius Ptolemy. These can be viewed as literary and cultural examples of ancient thinkers directly related to Phoenician cultural influence, but who were called Greek in the 20th century due mainly to Athens, Greece and Rome being located in Europe, and to cultural habits related to Euro-centrism.
    Several ancient scholars were very likely in the cultural sphere of influence of the city of Carthage.
    The city of Berytus (Beirut) had an important law school that lasted until the 6th century CE.

  • Ergun Aktëmur
    Ergun Aktëmur Year ago +9

    This type of colonization is similar to portuguese colonization, since Portugal had a small population but outstanding soldiers. The portuguese usually took coastal areas and didn't advance inland.

    • A B
      A B Year ago +5

      Not really
      Pheonicians used other people for war affair
      They werent soldiers

    • Ergun Aktëmur
      Ergun Aktëmur Year ago +4

      @A B You're right. They rarely fought, for example the sacred band of Carthage.

    • Ergun Aktëmur
      Ergun Aktëmur Year ago +1

      YugoslavianMapping1291 [IMA] [YUC] [GBS] 💪💪💪

    • A B
      A B Year ago +4

      @Ergun Aktëmur they used Numidians/Lybics/Berbers, Celts, Iberians, Greeks for war

    • A B
      A B Year ago

      Mustafa 576 some of their generals were foreigners too

  • Nikiforos Antonopoulos

    Make one for greek colonies next

  • Yednekachew Geremew

    If there is one philosopher who walk all around the world Like Marco Pollo as trader and x as philosopher it would be ...

  • WatchnLearn
    WatchnLearn Year ago +2

    It is funny you used the name new town. Because that’s actual what it name really was. In Hebrew since it by default was a Hebrew colony

    • TuniStick
      TuniStick 11 months ago

      lol even in Penorep (my mothertongue, it's a language we speak in nothern spain) it's very obvious that "Qerțeċ" means new village, with Qerț meaning village or town and eċ the suffix of Eǐțeċ meaning modern or new. Lol how similair phoenician is to my language

  • Boom Taylor
    Boom Taylor Year ago +1

    This is amazing

  • lerneanlion
    lerneanlion Year ago +4

    The problem of colonization is that some of the colonists never respected the cultures of the natives at all! Sure, they respected the natives when they first arrived but as time passed, things always get intense and one side will fall. And sadly, it's usually the natives that lost in these wars.

    • Archangel17
      Archangel17 Year ago +2

      I don't know if it is usually the natives that lost, or rather that the times the natives won where just forgotten. Kind of like we know a lot of battles where mounted knights were (unexpectedly) defeated, but most of the battles involving knights just where never mentioned/remembered unless it had great significance on the region/history.
      Bias to historical significance and unexpected events

  • Alparslan Korkmaz
    Alparslan Korkmaz Year ago +1

    Nicely explained.

  • amazing unboxing
    amazing unboxing Year ago +1

    Such a nice video!!! You have a new subscriber here💞💕💞💕💞💕💞💞💞💕💞

  • Giovanni Cardoso
    Giovanni Cardoso Year ago +8

    The portuguese capital of Lisbon was founded by the phoenicians.

    • Cedars
      Cedars Year ago

      It was a settlement before the Phoenicians arrived there and made it a more important trading post.

    • Giovanni Cardoso
      Giovanni Cardoso Year ago

      @Cedars So was pretty much every ancient major city before someone supposedly "founded it"

    • Cedars
      Cedars Year ago

      @Giovanni Cardoso For the most part, maybe. But Carthage was said to be founded on virgin soil according to ancient sources. Archaeological evidence confirms this. The Phoenicians founded cities and colonized or re-founded others.

  • SM K
    SM K Year ago +5

    Scientists underestimate positive interaction between Phoenicians and Greeks, even as early as the 12th c BCE. Besides post-#LateMycenaeanIIIC Cyprus, they also used #Crete, #Pholegandros, #Kea/#Ceos, and other #GreekIslands, as trading stations and stepping stones for further expeditions, trade, and colonization.

    • SM K
      SM K Year ago +1

      ‏ 𖤍ᴾᴴᴼᴱᴺᴵˣ Why not!? 🤷🏾‍♂️

    • SM K
      SM K Year ago

      ‏ 𖤍ᴾᴴᴼᴱᴺᴵˣ I'm a Yankee 🇺🇲 , as well as a citizen of the World. Why ?

  • Илија Гајић

    How they menaged to lose all of it is a even better question.

    • Simon Colin
      Simon Colin Year ago +3

      Phoenicia itself was disunited and actually very small, so didnt had a chance against the heavily militarized Persian Empire.
      The colonies which were let alone (including Carthago) were absorbed by the Romans after the 2 punic wars (Roma VS Carthago).

    • Mouath
      Mouath Year ago

      @Simon Colin I don't think he was awaiting such a response.. it is definitely a good question considering that Carthage (totally independent from Phoenicia) had major possessions all over the ancient world and was so advanced it could be described as post-WII USA of the ancient world, yet lost to some barbarians in central Italy who didn't control much of their surroundings when Carthage was busy mining the Americas and exploring Cameroon. Talk about an unfair world from the start.

  • Facundo Cadaa
    Facundo Cadaa 11 months ago

    What do you mean by "phallus socratic"? I've tried to search for that term but only got either the socratic method or prostitution in ancient Greece

  • thearab59
    thearab59 Year ago +6

    There was, as I understand it, no such thing as Phoenicia, just as, a little bit later, no such thing as Greece. These civilisations were competing city states. So, in time, were many of the colonies.
    We should not impose modern concepts on the past.

    • GM Duda Fanclub
      GM Duda Fanclub Year ago +1

      Oh but trust me during many times in history they were unified, with one king ruling many cities
      In fact, they were during peaceful times somewhat independent
      However, during war time, they would all act as one nation with one identity

    • Miguel Padeiro
      Miguel Padeiro Year ago +1

      No one is talking about a Greek nation or Phonecian nation when we talk about Ancient Greece and Phonecia. We call them civilizations, which is absolutely correct. All these different polities belonged to one civilization.

  • Matthew
    Matthew 22 days ago

    Great video!

  • 2020’s
    2020’s Year ago +4

    Respect Phoenicians from USA 3000 years later

    • Mouath
      Mouath Year ago +3

      We Carthaginians discovered the Americas long before the spaniards or the vikings.

    • 2020’s
      2020’s Year ago +1

      @Mouath respect

    • Mouath
      Mouath Year ago +1

      @Miguel Padeiro You seem to have a problem with the term "Carthaginian". it isn't a culture, it's an identity. "we" means those who identify as Carthaginian, i was born and raised in Carthage, that's the original name of our nation before the romans changed it into Africa.

  • enjoymfs
    enjoymfs Year ago +7

    Phonecians firstly colonized cyprud and inhabitated that area. Then ancient greeks colonized all of mediterrenean area and assimilated local people. Modern greek speaking cypriots are phonecians, modern Greek speaking anatolians are Native anatolians and modern greek speaking pontus people are georgians. Unfortunatelly they think they are greek

  • RPM
    RPM Year ago

    Hi what software do you use to do your videos?

  • Ali G
    Ali G Year ago +2

    proud to be from tyre, south lebanon.
    so much history there

    • TuniStick
      TuniStick 11 months ago +1

      proud to be from Cathage 🙂🙂

  • Sergi Curero
    Sergi Curero 9 months ago +2

    ibiza is the island to the south, not the one in the middle

  • Theo Vas
    Theo Vas 9 months ago

    The idea that greeks adopted and improved the Phoenician alphabet has so many gaps. I hope one day everyone of you would read ancient greek and understand that even philosophers like Plato spoke about this topic. For example Plato said that greek language has connections with letters, meanings and the word origin. We have examples of ancient greek alphabets by 5000 years before Christ and even at the period of Trojan war. Some philosophers like Aristotle named another philosopher, whose name was Palamidis, and is believed that he saved some letters of the alphabet. This conversation would last forever and at the end of the day its a fault of greek politics, because we educate our youngers only knowing this possible scenario. Quite funny to think that ancient greeks with so many different alphabets from 12.000 to 700, adopted an alphabet from another civilization, like they didnt have their own. Remember what plato said "every word in greek has a meaning and everything is perfectly combined", this is why you can generate new words from every word and letter. An alphabet of another nation couldn't fit so well and history shows this really well. Finally, the whole idea of Indo-European languages family is a mess without important evidences

  • سامي داوود
    سامي داوود 13 days ago

    The Phoenicians are the Canaanites, and the Canaanites are descended from Oraib Ibn Amaleek Ibn Laoith (عريب ابن عمليق ابن لاوذ), and they are from the ancient Arabs.
    The Phoenician Empire is an ancient Arab colonial empire and they were famous for being the masters of the seas. Their descendants today are the sons of the coasts in Syria, Lebanon and Palestine. This empire colonized the coasts of the Mediterranean Sea from north to south and built many settlements in the Italian peninsula, the Iberian peninsula and the Mediterranean islands, The most prominent of these colonies is the ancient Andalusia in Iberia, which was exterminated by the Romans and the Gothic people, and rebuilt by the Arab Umayyads when they conquered Iberia after Islam, and among the most prominent Phoenician colonies is the civilization of Carthage in North Africa, and Emperor Hani Baal, known as Hannibal, is an Arab Phoenician Canaanite emperor who threatened Rome in its land and he threat to remove it from history, It is said that the Phoenician and the Arab Thamudians reached the Americas and settled there, and many of the American Indians in the Americas are descendants of the Thamudians and Canaanites (Phoenicians)

  • - Cronitor -
    - Cronitor - Year ago

    Increasing their trade network. Well basically like the early Portuguese and Spanish.

  • Rima Calid
    Rima Calid Year ago

    I hope someday someone talks about their settlements in the black sea and Celtic shores and beyond

    • Alex
      Alex Year ago +2

      There is no modern evidence to support the idea that Pheonicians settled in Western Europe or the Black sea. If by Celtic shores you mean Northern Spain and Southern France or northen italy, then yeah they had commerce with them but no colonies. The claim they reach the British Isles is highly doubted. Some say they went there to trade tin which was abundant... but modern scholars have studied the archeology and other documents and has been proven that they talk about Galicia in Northwestern Spain (which is closer and makes way more sense). Galicia had some celtified culture and had large amounts of tin they traded with with the pheonicians.

  • TuniStick
    TuniStick 11 months ago +2

    Fun Fact!! We didn't extinct we're still living in small populations in northern Spain and southern France and having our own semetic language too ... but ... ya know it's influenced by Spanish

  • Kim Jong-un
    Kim Jong-un Year ago +12

    Just got back from Tyre... *they have wheely good business*
    the Phoenicians are impressive but not as impressive as the fact that 15 minutes can save you 15 percent or more on car insurance from GEICO

    • Niall Murphy
      Niall Murphy Year ago +2

      Ah kim, your despotic way always raise a chuckle

  • bcv~xx
    bcv~xx 9 months ago +1

    The Phoenicians are the greatest European civilization. They were the first advanced civilization in Europe. Byblos is the oldest city not only in Europe, but in the world.

    • Theo Vas
      Theo Vas 9 months ago

      Bro Byblos is in Middle east, not europe. The whole idea that Israel is a european country is only approved in football matches and other events 😂

    • E
      E 9 months ago

      You can make the argument that the were part of "Western Civilization" but they surely weren't European, not ethnically or geographically.

    • Theo Vas
      Theo Vas 8 months ago

      علئ ياسر so you are telling me that if a european nation colonise a place outside of europe, after many years the new place will become a european country? You probably mean that the civilization and movements are to the west and the cultural share is different from the other close nations. But that doesnt mean anything. Australia isn't considering a european country for example. Sure Israel is a different scenario because of religion and arab neighbors, but remember that being a Jew is different than being israeli.

  • Raphael Andrews
    Raphael Andrews Year ago

    We did not lean very much about Phoenicians apart from trading which we already knew.

  • LIONBOY ☀️Король Кошек☀️

    🤺☦️🇷🇺That's not the point. Point is that it shows just how accurate the description of them and their trade route in the Bible, and what the curse upon the Canaanites meant in being "slave of slaves to his brothers"

  • kisshore kumar M
    kisshore kumar M 6 months ago

    Please try to bring videos Indian ( Bharat) oldest Civilisation, it will be great.......

  • PakBall & Sam
    PakBall & Sam Year ago +13

    At this time the Greeks who were settled around them were for the most part Ionians, and after being taught the letters by the Phoenicians, they used them with a few changes of form. In so doing, they gave to these characters the name of Phoenician, as was quite fair seeing that the Phoenicians had brought them into Greece."
    (5-58-59)”
    ― Herodotus, The Histories

  • grammarpirate
    grammarpirate Year ago +2

    Its weird that u placed Carthage far south than where it really was and u placed Ibiza on Mallorca

    • Amr Faham
      Amr Faham Year ago

      he has to work more on his maps, for example he should have inckuded tge Syrian coast too. the fist alphabet started there

  • جيم و سين
    جيم و سين Year ago +10

    North Africa is a Punic Civilization. Cuerta, Cirta or Constantine was the capital of Algerian 🇩🇿 Phoenicians before the so called Massenssen backstabbed them with Romans and took over. Phoenicians settled peacefully and mixed with Africans. Like greeks did with Ancient Egyptians.

    • Adrian Major
      Adrian Major Year ago +4

      You got the story completely wrong. Punic is a later development of Phoenician culture in North Africa (and surrounding areas), characterized by a more and more Libyan/Berber element culturally and linguistically (the phonology of Punic is clear example of simplification due to Libyan influence) as well as other Southern European, Greek and Egyptian input. This is even supported by dna evidence from Phoenician remains in Sardinia, where earlier remains were Levantine and Levantine+Sardinian mixes, while later remains from the more Punic proper era were more Berber and mixed Sardinian, other types of Europeans and Berber.
      As for Cirta, it was initially a Berber settlement (like most Phoenician ones in North Africa), and was not a "capital" of Algeria since Algeria starts to exist only with the French colonization.
      So no, North Africa is not a Punic civilization, but Punic civilization was one among several civilization of North Africa.

    • Miguel Padeiro
      Miguel Padeiro Year ago +1

      The Romans then kind of exterminated western punic civilization, North Africa is no longer punic culturally

  • Belakeb
    Belakeb 5 months ago

    I'm algerian arabic phoenician and I'm proud

  • Phoenician Cedars
    Phoenician Cedars Year ago +2

    For the past 100 years and more, the Arabs have been trying to completely annihilate the true identity of Lebanon (Phoenicia). Currently it is the Persians turn with the likes of hizbullah, but we will NEVER give up our true Canaanite who later became known as Phoenicians identity. Thank you for shedding light on our proud history that has shaped ancient southern European culture and history, Phoenicians even reached the Americas both north and south supported by evidence from New England and Brazil. ♥️🇱🇧♥️

    • Amr Faham
      Amr Faham Year ago

      phenocians started in Syria too and they were assimilated long before the Arabs. all what you're talking about is historical fantasy, nothing relevant.

  • free man
    free man 6 months ago

    The Canaanian Phoenicians ancestors of the Arabs are the first original peoples who settled in North Africa in 1 and century BC before the Berbers and the Byzantines

    The Canaanian Phoenicians ancestors of the Arabs are the first original peoples who settled in North Africa in 1 and century BC before the Berbers and the Byzantines

  • Drswag 007
    Drswag 007 Year ago

    along with Carthage came the kingdoms of Numidia and Mauritania. the former encompasses modern northern Algeria and the later the kingdom of Moracco.

    • Slimane Ismailli
      Slimane Ismailli Year ago

      And Afrikya. Mauretania ( Mooretania ) Numidia and Al Afrikya. Carthage was in Afrikya

  • 3omar
    3omar Year ago +10

    Thanks for this video bro❤️🇱🇧

    • 3omar
      3omar Year ago

      YugoslavianMapping1291 [IMA] [YUC] [GBS] ok

  • Titanosaurus
    Titanosaurus 11 months ago

    Is nobody talking about this coinciding with the end of Bronze Age Collapse?

  • kasper41291
    kasper41291 Year ago

    As a gay man I love these videos and It warms me that you support us lgbt+ people ❤️

  • Vasile Rogojan
    Vasile Rogojan Year ago +2

    I should admit that I didn't know barely anything about the Phoenicians.

    • TuniStick
      TuniStick 11 months ago

      we're still living in spain (at least descendents) 🙂✌️

  • Raph L Vlogs
    Raph L Vlogs  Year ago +1

    the Mediterranean Sea is a miniature ocean.

  • legionandglory
    legionandglory Year ago

    skanderbeg part 2 please!!!

  • Abadyr
    Abadyr Year ago

    1:35 "A phallus socratic civilization" hum? Interesting!
    I was afraid it might only be Thalassocratic.

  • Raph L Vlogs
    Raph L Vlogs  Year ago +1

    were early modern colonial empires inspired by the Phoenicians?

    • Simon Colin
      Simon Colin Year ago +3

      Nah, they were inspired by Rome, which was inspired by Carthage and the Greeks, which were both inspired by the Phoenicians.

    • Miguel Padeiro
      Miguel Padeiro Year ago +1

      I wouldn't say inspired at all, but definitely had a paralel evolution.
      Portugal was the first global empire. It was very much like phonecia's. Portugal had several outposts across Africa, the Indian Ocean and China (Macau) and Japan (Nagasaki). These were built to trade with the locals and ease future travels for merchants...and of course:
      CONTROL THE SPICE TRADE. HE WHO CONTROL THE SPICE CONTROLS THE UNIVERSE
      Then we have empires like Spain, who went more to the textbook empire route, akin to Rome. The grand land conquests of Mesoamerica and the Incas, creating a vast land empire

    • Cedars
      Cedars Year ago

      @Simon Colin No, they were most definitely inspired by the Phoenicians as well.

  • Aloy
    Aloy Year ago

    phoenicia best nicia, i like their k flag symbol its like an A too

  • E H
    E H Year ago

    1:34 Phallo-Socratic civilization

  • T'ien Hsiang Bai
    T'ien Hsiang Bai Year ago

    can anyone tell me what "phallus socratic" in 1:38 mean?Is the subtitle wrong or I misheard?

    • T'ien Hsiang Bai
      T'ien Hsiang Bai Year ago

      OK,I listened again,I guess it may be "thalassocratic"

    • TuniStick
      TuniStick 11 months ago

      dya turn on subtitles?

  • Dail Kutinski
    Dail Kutinski Year ago

    Keep it on.

  • Billy Kotsos
    Billy Kotsos Year ago

    With a lot of blood sweat and tears !