Tap to unmute
Why this expert says Vladimir Putin won't stop at Ukraine
Embed
- Published on Jan 30, 2023 veröffentlicht
- President Vladimir Putin is looking to restore the Russian empire, and he won't stop with the elimination of Ukraine, says Russia expert Keir Giles.
»»» Subscribe to CBC News to watch more videos: bit.ly/1RreYWS
Connect with CBC News Online:
For breaking news, video, audio and in-depth coverage: bit.ly/1Z0m6iX
Find CBC News on Facebook: bit.ly/1WjG36m
Follow CBC News on Twitter: bit.ly/1sA5P9H
For breaking news on Twitter: bit.ly/1WjDyks
Follow CBC News on Instagram: bit.ly/1Z0iE7O
Subscribe to CBC News on Snapchat: bit.ly/3leaWsr
Download the CBC News app for iOS: apple.co/25mpsUz
Download the CBC News app for Android: bit.ly/1XxuozZ
»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»
For more than 80 years, CBC News has been the source Canadians turn to, to keep them informed about their communities, their country and their world. Through regional and national programming on multiple platforms, including CBC Television, CBC News Network, CBC Radio, CBCNews.ca, mobile and on-demand, CBC News and its internationally recognized team of award-winning journalists deliver the breaking stories, the issues, the analyses and the personalities that matter to Canadians.
Keir Giles poured honey into my ears - absolutely spot on in his analysis!!
Thank you for a clear and well explained item.
Who isn't an expert these days
you
@Tim Grant lol at least I'm original . Have an awesome weekend.
You?
Mostly people who “did their own research” by looking at the first page of google results.
@Paula Virany he's a real Bagdad bob and twice as false. He gives great talks at pregeru and Frazier institute though. Amazing eccos. None history. he's a cult member too boot ya know?. course you do. ya got the insight for sure. I can tell.
Mr. Giles is bang-on in delineating the issue.
It's telling that Estonia, Latvia, Poland and Lithuania are providing the largest support for Ukraine by % of GDP.
This is a view that's been held since the end of WW2 but the west has never gone full in on their support. Even in Vietnam, the Americans held back. And when the Russians invaded Afghanistan the west just gave the radicals modern weapons which ultimately came back to haunt the US. Moving forward, the US invaded Afghanistan, albeit under very different conditions, ended up failing because they didn't realize they weren’t just fighting ISIS/taliban, they were up against a religion that created a culture that didn't want change.
Now we have the Ukraine, which is a completely different kettle of fish. And quite frankly, I believe beyond the Ukraine, Russia's young population who want to move on from the old imperialistic ways. Think about how monumental that is. Russia has never really known democracy. I'm hoping that a Ukrainian victory would result in a much bigger shift in the region.
@Alok Sen They didn't look for an enemy in Ukraine.
Finally a no-nonsense, factual reporting of Russia's objectives.
Cato said it: "Russia delenda est!"
Impressive clarity!
impressive lie. might as well be a pregerU add. lost.
Nevel Chamberlain knows this but he learned it the hard way.
@Volodymyr V who needs satellites when the "great Russians" keep exposing their location via cell phones lmao
Please invite a guest with expertise on the Minsk Agreements.
@Barry Bazzer Did you whine/cry when Canada invaded and occupied Afghanistan for 13 years, like you whine/cry over Russia?
Russia has invaded its neighbors 7 times since Putin. Each time he snatches some land; is suddenly all about peace and "ready to negotiate"; then, he picks up where he left off. He is provoked by weakness, not strength. Hang in there, Ukraine, help is on the way.
Honour may not win power, but it wins respect. And respect earns power. Today is victory over yourself of yesterday; tomorrow is your victory over lesser men. A warrior is worthless unless he rises above others and stands strong in the midst of a storm.
@anna b Did you whine/cry when Canada invaded and occupied Afghanistan for 13 years?
@Clip-Share music .. do you whine/cry for First Nations people of Canada?
Did you whine/cry when Canada invaded and occupied Afghanistan for 13 years?
@Terminal Insanity warmongers dont have to fight if there is nothing worth fighting for. let the economies fall into disarray and have everyone feed and fend for themselves in the aftermath.
Wut? Warmongers should be given front line seats to their wars.
Didn’t they say they wanted more after Ukraine
This guy is spot on.
Giles spewing nonsense.....and Katie gobbling it up as 'truth'
Did you whine/cry when Canada invaded and occupied Afghanistan for 13 years?
lol
👏👏👏👏👏
The most sensible speaker I have heard on this subject (along with others such as Kasparov, Browder, Khodorkovsky) who have a clear and firm understanding of what Putin is, his methods and what is at stake for the civilised world......
@Clip-Share music Hey we were there for 20 years of stupidity. be fair
@Carlo B Canada invaded and occupied Afghanistan for 13 years; did you whine/cry about it?
@Clip-Share music stick to the topic at hand backwater dwelling Razi
Did you whine/cry when Canada invaded and occupied Afghanistan for 13 years?
Excellent speaker--amazed that he has such a perfect understanding of the situation!
@EBZ California belongs to Mexico as does Texas. If Russia can take back land it gave away then Mexico should get California and Texas and Russia should get Alaska back. Are you happy with that???
@Tom Katin
👣🐒🌿🍅
calling a psychopath an expert is like showing yourself as mental patient CBC news .. hahaha
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
The minister pretend that this "sovereign state" didnt have meddling in its political affairs
dont need war make peace
@anna b Did you whine/cry when Canada invaded and occupied Afghanistan for 13 years ?
@Clip-Share music .. do you whine/cry for First Nations people of Canada?
@Иван Снежков Did you whine/cry when Canada invaded and occupied Afghanistan for 13 years?
People need to grow up in order for us to have peace. In France at the moment, Argentinians are being badly treated because they beat the French national team in the World Cup. The mentality of most adults is the same as a three year old's. How can you expect peace in these circumstances?
Going from a clash/ difference to openly stating they’re at war is a rather quick conclusion to jump to.. couldn’t one say that the west has been at war with Russia since 1991? 🤔 why did the west reject Russia’s application to NATO? Wouldn’t this have helped.. 🤷♂️
Russia never applied to join NATO. In 2000, Putin then acting President of Russia supposedly asked the then-NATO chief when Russia would be invited to join NATO. The answer was simple, one isn’t invited vote join, one applies to join. Russia never did. Besides, I thought their whole deal was that NATO had promised (NATO didn't) not to expand further east? One could say that the west been at war with Russia since 1991, and that is exactly what Putin is saying. One would be wrong, and Putin is wrong. Ukraine should have made giving up their nukes conditional on NATO membership.
Omg finally. Words I can relate ☝️😊🤔🤔🤔🪝
Actually I would like to hear him say that himself, in English, as I never have to date!
Russia is acting like a capitalist: They want to expand their business, companies must grow nowadays so Russia also must grow. Companies don't care about pollution, environment, expoiting people... but only money is important and share-holders (Oligards).
Acting capitalist? The Soviet Union collapsed in 1991.
Did you whine/cry when Canada invaded and occupied Afghanistan for 13 years?
This is what democracy is all about.
He's 100% correct.
Dammit that stream running down through my neighbor's meadow is mine. I have a nice moving Creek on the south side but I want the one in my neighbors also because it was meant to be mine.
@tukhorse I agree with you, for context, I was responding to the guy who was suggesting, like so many proponents of Putin's invasion, that he had a valid reason for doing so.
@You're not on fire yet. At 65 I like to think that I was raised by the world war 2 generations. And throughout my life they left me with one thought ,who in the hell would pass a war on to their children and grandchildren. I mean I could squeeze around off just as easy as anyone but who in the hell would want to start something like that. No way to justify and no excuse for for that little fella in Russia to pull this crap. If he's in my front yard I'd have take him to feed the hogs one time
@plantbasedstrong you gotta ask yourself "do my neighbors have an issue with me, and why?"
Then you look back over 80 years of history and go, " oh"
@plantbasedstrong its still HIS creek
imagine i showed up at your house tomorrow claiming that you did all that to your creek (with no investigation proving it) and said your creek was now mine.
would you give up your creek just like that??
True☝️☝️ he speaks the truth
I agreed Russia will never stop just claiming Ukraine alone he will want more.
2014 fool me once never again
Russia and Ukraine must get United and bring eternal peace for their nations.
Peace 🇷🇺❤🇺🇦
it is not up to you or Russia to unite with an unwilling partner. That is called aggression.
Finally I found an expert that is totally right!
The very early Moscowy citizenship origins are from Sweden. Sweden is part of NATO (or will be very soon) which mean it is inevitable for Russia to become, sooner or later, part of NATO too. Leaving Africa, China, South/Central America, and the Indo-Pacific as non-NATO.
Excuse me? Sweden doesn't speak for Russia, or Denmark, or Poland, or Ukraine. It certainly doesn't speak for Russia. Sweden speaks for itself as an independent sovereign nation; no one else.
Russia can choose to try to join NATO, but they've got a long row to hoe to fulfill the terms and conditions necessary for NATO membership (being an active functioning democracy is one of the first requirements). In addition, I don't know how many other NATO countries would vote to accept them in.
@abb abb Miscegenation? "... they took over as leaders of Slavic tribes..." all said!
Wrong Moscow didn't even exist when Ruriks came to what is now Russian territory .. also don't confuse Russia with Ryc' two different kingdoms
Also Ruriks' aka Vikings who came were not majority or the population .... they took over as leaders of Slavic tribes' .... that doesn't make Ryc' population Swedish it was mainly Slavic..
Turkey does not fit NATOs mojo.
@Terminal Insanity Yeah, China likes to watch the development of the other regions of the world so it may assess the best conditions to take Taiwan.
A book that should be widely read about the Clear and Present Danger that Russia is, and won't be going away.
Send Ukraine all the weapons, artillery, tanks, and fighter jets that it needs. Now. Not too little too late, a lot and early!
Russia empire in means soviet union..💀
Great story for a cheap book, but not for the level of an expert.
I am Russia/Ukraine and he explained everything perfectly well.
u dont not need an expert for that
This so called expert is here to promote his book. He is simply a reporter that worked for a while in Russia. He has written stories for CNN, so you know the value of his words.
@Alvaro Q I think you are making Diane's point for her.
@Chiggen was gona say ..lol
@@PrettyPink🌸
I'm called Wang Ai Hua but you can call me Miss Wang!
And what are you called? Trouble maker?
It’s good that the expert knows how to guide our options and thoughts, I learned from this to hate Russia, support Ukraine, and think the west is always good. CBC is a good news agency and should be funded even more to protect us from disinformation.
We don't know that for sure but what we know for sure is nato did not stop at Germany like they promised
This program has become unbearable boring since Vassy left. You need to find someone with an actual personality to host the show. I end up tuning this host out no matter the topic. She's just boring as a host. I actually started watching the CBC because of Vassy and as an American felt like I could actually get factual news about my country that was unbiased through the network. I love several of the other journalist's on the network. This one just doesn't have the right tone inflections for the job and keeping the audience's attention. I'm sorry I'm just saying it as I see it.
the quality of CBC reporters is extremely low, the sooner we stop subsidizing it the better
I pray President Putin don't drink, and finds A.A. amen
As Russia win looms inevitable, watch MSM slow pivots to assign blame to Ukrainian corruption. Adequate face saving exit strategy to shift from arms dealing to country rebuilding. Though NATO expansion halted, monied interests always win 🤑
@everyday tenor he's realistic
@EBZ Well done comrade.
This is Russia's historic land and sphere of influence just as Germany and france is the UK and us sphere of influence. We have no business getting involved in their sphere of influence
@MindBomb he also said the same thing about Ukraine. And also said that when Putin decides to fight a serious war against Ukraine - Ukraine will have no chance.
USA sent 1 million dumb 155m rounds and only 5k precise 155mm rounds, so only 0.4% of Ukrainian shells are precise. Do you think this number is lower for Russia? Why?
According to many mercs who left Ukraine (like Wali) ukrainians receive 1-3 days of training before being sent to the frontline. Compare it to 1-3 months of Russian extra training (on top of at least 1 year of training all Russian men received when they were 18) even if training wasn't that great
All equipment NATO sent to Ukraine has equal or superior Russian analogues in far larger quantities
But... Zelensky is Churchill. Are you suggesting he's actually The Godfather?
This guys is a cheerleader for the military industrial complex and the american war machine.
🙅🏻
Thank you for having Comments ON for a change.
Not wanting to hear from us tax payers that support CBC is not democratic at all but very dictatorial
@You're not on fire yet. , I get your point, but they are a little heavy handed with their monitoring, in my opinion.
If you can't be responsible with something you don't get it, that's all it is, nothing to do with democracies or dictatorships.
pretty sure comment sections are relatively brand new in human history when it comes to the public getting their news
😂😂😂
Ukraine must make thier own nuklear weapons!
guy is 1,70cm lol
of course he has to compensate
Exactly restore he’s absolutely right
He'll stop when we stop him.
We or you mean Ukrainians,
Ukrainians*
you want think how can save people
This will be aftwe Ukraine he has a long way to go and it won’t even work
Selling his book I see
not solison war ?
What the heck is solison?
next is ... Texas !!!
He will, his day is near
And the pigs wont stop at Iraq Syria and Libya and Iran.
both are mis udentersading
Putin needs to be introduced to Bin ladin by the United states.
USA didnt stop at yugoslavia.
Another expert...
@Cellar Door Did you whine/cry when Canada invaded and occupied Afghanistan for 13 years?
@Cellar Door an expert in propaganda
And who are you? lmao
Invite Victoria Nuland, she can explain what's going on now
You cannot negotiate with terrorists. Hence the end is nigh.
We al nowe how dictators wil end also madman Putin
Get a real expert ... John Meirshimer predicted this conflict back in 2014. And he gives Reason. And it's not that putin wants to be Peter the great. Why would put wait until nato is at his borders and ukraine is armed to the teeth to make his imperial ambitious move. Absurd.
💙💛💙💛💙🇺🇦💛🇨🇦✊🖖🌻
order and chaos... conventionaly russia cant ...but with nukes it may..
i thought russia has something but..now .they cant even take ukraine..so..😁 ..soon they will loose moscow. ..
@Eulas walker walker 🤣
We ain't giving up moscow tennessee
For those that do not want to support ukraine... they will feaal in pain... following the steps of europe... in the 193x... :D
@Clip-Share music they succeded but nato do not make genocides like the russians, so they would leave after the changing regime... obviously no revolution can be made from outside... so that regime fall...
@Sun Shine Yea he probably won't. That's why I think this will last at least 5 years.
@KX8276 NATO couldn't even succeed in Afghanistan...
Very strange logic - "a little" far from reality.
But if you like it, feel free to do so.;)
lolz
Lying is not a good thing sir
WEF MEDIA
No one thinks he would stop with just Ukraine
@Chelsea Nolen then why are you saying you disagree? It's very obvious he would keep going if he wins
Украины уж нет. Одна видимость которую поддерживает запад. Запад запустил режим самоуничтожения и даже не видит этого.
Would NATO stop at Ukraine?
yes, unless russia wants to join
"expert"
"Expert"....
Heavy long range missiles, tanks and jets. Chase that bear back to hell. Slava Ukraine! 🇨🇦🇺🇦
One thing clear as day, Ukraine is done, for sure , there is no debate about that.🤣
Это было понятно сразу. А вот почему запад не видит что запустил режим саоуничтожейния для меня загадка. Это агония.
Nothing new here .. we already know that !! The US has been slow trickling weapons to Ukraine because they want to extend this war as much as they can, in order to weaken Putin and Russia as much as they can for centuries to come, and not allowing them to rebuild their weapons capabilities, hence the draconian sanctions. The US is also learning a lot and training all its war factions who are running this war on the strategies of war games. The US strives to create a balance between both sides so this war takes longer to end. Remember the Iran -Iraq war where the US was arming both sides and giving satellite images of troops for both sides.
Lately this new news anchor is really boring … not to mention embarrassingly morbidly obese, not an image we want to promote in Canada, we want to show a health conscience image so we don’t become like our neighbours to the south with rampant diabetes and heart disease
Ukraine asked the US for weapons 🤦🏾♂️
Remember: Pointing with your finger at someone means also that there are three other fingers pointing at you.
Don't tell bullshit propaganda
us used nukes ..so ...this guy is lost..in his own argument. 🤣
Expert 😂
Expert liar for sure.
Propaganda
I'm more interested in "why journalists or others think Putin will stop in Ukraine"?
CBC news is always crap.
Disappointing that this is on CBC , I feel sorry for the “ journalists “ having to elicit the same old simplistic conclusions that fit the script . Yawn
@@PrettyPink🌸 fu
Go to sleep then and don't bother writing comments!
This guy draws a paycheck from China 🤦🏻♂️
Expert? 😂😂😂
Don't try to be so innocent, if that is true then why Usa build Nato army across all the boundaries of Russia????
The USA didn't build ANYTHING across all the boundaries of Russia. Those other countries (Finland, Poland, Latvia, Estonia, Lithuania, etc) chose to join NATO shortly after they became independent, sovereign countries. And I'm sure you agree that countries get to choose the path they will take without interference from other countries.
Your history is questionable.
Why Russia not claiming back Alaska. No country sells property to another country
Uh, America purchased Alaska from Russia. And they purchased the western half of the country from France (look up Louisiana Purchase).
Louisiana Purchase?
Talking fast is not the same as intelligence.
NATO-trained and NATO-supplied Ukrainian army keeps retreating.
Slava Zukkini!
calling a psychopath an expert is like showing yourself as mental patient CBC news .. hahaha
I assume unlike those other trolls u have articles backing that assertion up....I mean you wouldn't intentionally make yourself look a fool so u must have something
Russia will not loose
lol cope
Who is even right in this matter?
same experts telling us vaccines are safe and effective
Stop spreading lies on about mother Russia 🇷🇺
GLORY TO RUSSIA 🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺💪💪💪
A liar and propagandist is now called an expert?
BS
Such convincing rebuttal, we are all grateful for your input.
True
Bla bla bla ....bey bey putin.
Putin wears high heels 👠 we're all in trouble when a dictator wears high heels
@Chiggen thanks for reminding me of this great movie that I saw when I was young... A husband who wants nothing more than to see his kids. At the time though, just a comedy, but now..a tragedy. I have too many friends in this situation. Robbin Williams on late night was sometimes too much. But I can't think of a movie were he didn't give his all.
@@PrettyPink🌸 sorry man, I'm not sure what your getting at. no I don't drive a truck. Actually I ride a bicycle. It's good exercise, you should try it sometime. Even ride it here in Canada at -10c with snow on the ground.
@mike sorensen Trucker, are you? 🚛
I thought here in the west, we are encouraging our young boys that wearing high heels is socially acceptable. What's your problem dude? Not up with the times or are you not as progressive as you claim to be?
That sounds like discrimination. No problem though when a dictator wears blackface.